During the evening of Halloween in 1975, 15-year-old Martha Moxley was beaten and stabbed to death outside her home in the affluent Connecticut town of Greenwich. Despite the shocking nature of the crime and several neighbourhood suspects, nobody was arrested or charged with Martha's murder. Over 20 years later, Mark Fuhrman, the cop whose reputation had been sullied during the OJ Simpson trial, reopened the case in his new role as a private investigator. Fuhrman found evidence pointing towards the Skakel brothers, Michael and Tommy, who are related to the Kennedys and who were interviewed by the police back in 1975. Considering the salacious material at his disposal, director Tom McLoughlin fails to generate much interest, let alone suspense, in this TV-movie reconstruction, which has the gimmicky approach of having the victim speak directly to camera.

The story of Martha Moxley, a 15-year-old girl murdered in Greenwich in the 1970s. Her murder went unsolved for 25 years.